Thanksgiving Day without pumpkin pie isn’t anything worth celebrating in my book. Might as well be a plain and normal Thursday in March where Mom happened to buy a bird two sizes too big, leaving enough leftovers to feed the entire neighborhood for a week.
With all the butter-laden veggies, breadcrumb-topped casseroles and warmed rolls on the menu, there’s plenty to avoid at the dinner table if you have food allergies. Pumpkin pie doesn’t have to be one of them!
Last week I made homemade sweetened condensed milk with eight different types of sweeteners. Granted, I don’t need eight cups of this milk for my side dishes and desserts this week, but I was curious how sweetened condensed milk would turn out if it were made with maple syrup, honey or raw sugar. (It comes out pretty darn good, in case you’re curious too!)
One batch of homemade coconut milk, tried two different sweeteners (organic coconut palm sugar and organic evaporated cane juice) and got to cooking. The results?
Yum, sweet yum.
The coconut sugar came out really dark, and the evaporated cane juice came out a light mocha color. Both are equally delicious and don’t taste much like coconut at all!
If you’re dairy-free, don’t skip out on pumpkin pie. Instead, volunteer to make it yourself and sub your own homemade sweetened condensed milk instead!
- Combine milk and sweetener in a medium saucepan. Whisk to dissolve sweetener over medium heat.
- When the milk begins to steam, lower the temperature to as low as possible.
- Dip a straw into the milk and use a permanent marker to draw a line on the straw, just above where the milk hit.
- Allow milk to reduce to half in size from what it first was, periodically checking with the straw and stirring. This took approximately 2 hours and 20 minutes for me.
- When milk is reduced by half, remove from heat and whisk in vanilla extract.
- Pour into a clean glass jar and allow to cool. Store in the refrigerator.
The milk sweetened with coconut sugar got much thicker than the one made with evaporated cane juice.
I did not strain either milk, but you might want to do this if you're looking for a super-creamy consistency. The remaining pieces of coconut and/or sugar were not large and would likely not be noticeable in pumpkin pie, but probably would in a pudding.
When I was a kid, my mom used to make me my own pumpkin pie. I simply cannot imagine a holiday without it. But I know lots of recipes call for sweetened condensed milk. So…
What’s your favorite Thanksgiving dessert?
Here are some other dairy-free recipes you might enjoy:
- Pumpkin Spiced Creamer
- Salted Caramel Apple Bars
- Hemp Milk
- Coconut Milk
- Cashew Milk
- Peanut Milk
- Rice Milk
- Almond Milk
Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. By making a purchase through those links, I will earn commission that helps to keep the lights on in the Crumbs house – with no additional cost to you. Thank you for supporting Crumbs in this way. Read my full disclosure statement here.