6 comments to Fresh Start Day 19: Make Yogurt (and arm your gut!)

  • Cathie

    I made it for the first time last weekend. It tastes fine, but it’s a little thin. Of course I buy fat free yogurt, and that’s already thin, so I shouldn’t be too surprised by that. I read several different recipes/methods including Katie’s, and kind of figured it out on my own. I did use the crock pot, but I won’t next time. I will pour the cooled milk and yogurt directly into the jars, and I will probably use the cooler.

    I also had a bean coup this weekend. My local supermarket had a special 4 day sale, and I got them for .88/lb. Yay! You totally beat me on the apples though-got those for $1.29/lb on sale, which I was pretty happy with.

    • Tiffany

      Gotta go the full-fat route Cathie, for both yogurt consistency and the healthy fats! And whole milk too! Way to go on discounted beans – I would have had a very hard time restraining myself. Your apple deal is good too, don’t sell yourself short!

  • Asiyah

    Hello, I am definitely a supporter of making one’s own yogurt. When we lived in Syria, we could go around the corner and pick up fresh made yogurt any amount at any time. Great for a family with 5 children. When we returned to the US, we saw the price and said doing our own was best. I have done my own in the past but that was with only 3 in the family and a yogurt maker. I was not sure how to change up to make a larger amount and had to invent. Thankfully we have a large pot to fit 1 and 1/2 gal of milk. A good amount so we don’t have to make it too often. ( Approximately once a week unless we have alot of curries.) I found that heating it up to 180 degrees makes a nicely thickened yogurt although not as thick as greek yogurt. After the temperature goes back to 110 degrees, we mix our culture in well. Approximately 2 cups of the previous yogurt and the more whey the better. We then just place the pot with its lid into the oven, unheated, and leave for 9 to 12 hours. I usually try to make the yogurt in late afternoon or early evening so the ‘cook’ time is done through the night. Again, we do not heat the oven. It takes on the heat of the yogurt and stays pretty well. If super cold I have wrapped my pot loosely in heavy towels to help maintain the warmth. When the yogurt is done, we just take the pot to its own spot in the fridge. As we begin to use the yogurt, it does separate some leaving a portion that gets as thick as the Greek yogurt. We also sometimes make the yogurt cheese by letting the yogurt drain through a muslin cloth (or something like it) in a strainer in the fridge. Great for veggie and pita chip dips!

    As you can see, we are a major yourt family.

    • Tiffany

      Asiyah,

      I didn’t know the oven would take on the temperature of the pot and thus become an incubator on its own. Excellent! I’d like make yogurt cheese one of these days. Getting a dose of probiotics with a handful of pita chips sounds like a winner to me! ~Tiffany

Leave a Reply