14 comments to Fresh Start Day 15: Make Something From Scratch (skip the box!)

  • Cathie

    A few years ago I made cream of celery soup out of necessity (needed it for a recipe, didn’t have any.) It turned out so delicious that I won’t even consider buying it anymore. I have to say, that (super-easy) soup and bread have had the biggest “wow” response for homemade vs. store-bought. I did make yogurt this weekend, though. That was a learning experience, and the product was ok, but next time will be a little (hopefully a LOT) smoother.

  • Cathie

    Oh, and I just bought the book! ^

  • Amy

    I’ve started making “cream of ___” soups from scratch, as well. Yesterday, I made cinnamon applesauce and apple butter. We’re in the process of converting to only homemade breads including sandwich bread (my 14 yr-old is my worst critic for this one.) I’ve also quit buying coffee “creamers” after your post on them. I was horrified when I read the ingredients. Thanks so much for all the wonderful info you provide on your blog!

    • Tiffany

      Mmmm…. we’re headed to the farmer’s market Friday for apples to make more apple butter. I’m happy to hear you quit the creamer habit. I cringe when I see others drink it. Thanks Amy!!

  • Well, I am having trouble with salad dressings. I cant bring myself to eat any store bought ones with all the chemicals and sugar in them, and have never made any myself. I am on a lifestyle change with my food, and right now am on a 10 day full sugar fast (no bread, pasta, sweets, ect.) I am diabetic and need to start somewhere, anyways, I want to eat salads and dont like them without something on them. So I am determined to make this work, and now with your encouragement I am going to attempt to make Ranch dressing! We will see how it goes. I just mostly wanted to tell you how much I love your site and all the info you give is astounding!! Another thing I just noticed above is Amy says something about coffee creamers, ugh, I will have to check that out, I cant drink coffee with out them! Right now its my only vice and downfall with this sugar fast.

    • Amy

      Correna,
      Bailey’s coffee creamers are actually made with cream (GASP-unbelievable, right?) I still try and make my own but I figure these are better than most. They do contain sugar so I’m not sure how they would work for you. Hope this helps!

      Also, don’t give up if the first Ranch dressing you try isn’t what you want. I probably tried 3 or 4 different ones before I found one that was more suited to my tastes. There are a ton of different recipes out there for homemade Ranch.

    • Tiffany

      Amy’s right about the dressings. Try halving or even quartering a batch before going full force. And remember that you can always add more spices, but they’re pretty sneaky to remove. ;) YOU CAN DO IT!!

      Thank you for your wonderful encouragement Correna! I’m thrilled to have you as a reader – good luck on your sugar fast (I’d be a gonner before it even started).

  • Gina

    I’ve been thinking about this one. I would like to know how to make my own greek yogurt and panko bread crumbs and pudding mix. Well I can make my own pudding,but I like putting it in my cakes so I would like to see if that can be done-haven’t googled it yet. I also would like to attempt my own buttermilk although it would seem that milk and vinegar do the trick for most things. Those are the top things I still buy,but would be healthier if I made them. Oh and my son would much prefer the cute little snack pack of pudding over my homemade pudding. What can I say he falls for the packaging! Oh and graham crackers as my son loves those things and I tried my own and it didn’t work out so hot,but will try again,but it’s hard wasting money on failed attempts.

    • Tiffany

      Gina,

      Greek yogurt is SO easy. Make the homemade version (check out the DIY post), chill for a day and then strain it over a fine mesh strainer. If you don’t have fine mesh, use a coffee filter and a regular strainer. I do 1cup portions (or so) and let it sit for about an hour. Scoop it into a new container, repeat with more yogurt. I then use the whey to ferment something else (cranberry sauce at Thanksgiving) or in place of coconut water in smoothies.

      I would imagine you could use your own pudding in cakes. Can’t see why not! Panko bread crumbs are just the insides of bread. If you have any extra bread, remove the crusts and lightly toast slices. Put in a food processor (or blender) and pulse until the right consistency. The vinegar/milk trick works well for most buttermilk recipes. Maybe a small package of cute reusable containers would bring smiles to your son? It would be $5 or so upfront, but financial and nutritional savings in the long run. Maybe a Valentine’s gift? ;)

      The elusive graham cracker! I stopped buying them, but haven’t tried my own yet. Annie’s bunnies come in graham flavor if you must have that flavor cracker, otherwise I’ve found that once the kids realize the crackers are gone (and not coming back anytime soon), they gravitate towards healthier options. Some types of crackers that are made to accompany cheese don’t have gross stuff, so that’s an option too. Salt & pepper flavors are plainish, but the kids have fun topping them with peanut butter and raisins or bananas!

      I understand the failed attempts. Before I try anything new, I decide if there’s a different option first. If not, I start with a half-batch for both ingredient cost and taste experimentation. If it doesn’t taste good, I try to repurpose to not waste the money (bad crackers to bread crumbs for baked chicken). If it’s a winner, see if there’s a way to make the same things with more frugal ingredients. It can definitely be a process, but it can truly pay off in the end!

      • Gina

        Thank you Those are all good suggestions. I will definitely be trying my own greek yogurt very soon! For the pudding I meant I put the dry mix in so I don’t know how I’d make a dry mix for it because I make pudding with milk and make it fresh. That’s a good idea to make partial batches in the beginning and find a reuse for it if possible. In fact it kinda rings a bell-is it possible you mentioned something like this before and I wasn’t listening-ha!=)

        • Tiffany

          You’re welcome! Thanks for the pudding explanation – I thought you meant made and ready to eat! (Which, by the way, nearly sent me rushing to the kitchen to bake a cake, lol!)

          What’s the purpose of the pudding – for moisture in the end? I thought I heard yogurt instead can do that, and sour cream too. Or organic powdered milk?

  • Thank you for your submission on Nourishing Treasures’ Make Your Own! Monday link-up.

    Check back tomorrow when the new link-up is running to see if you were one of the top 3 featured posts! :)

Leave a Reply